South African Cultural Observatory

Beyond the creative economy?

BY 31.10.17

IT IS conference planning season for the South African Cultural Observatory (SACO). This means an intense review of the trends and research emerging from the creative and cultural industries (CCIs) and the arts, culture and heritage (ACH) sectors. I spent three weeks recently travelling to Europe and the United Kingdom, which gave me some real first hand insight to some of the most pressing issues on the minds of many thinkers, academics, researchers, economists and policy-makers. There is much to be excited about. There is also much to be worried about.

As we plan the SACO’s third national conference, we have embraced the theme, ‘Beyond the creative economy? Trends and Issues in National and Regional Economies’. This means that we are considering a future trajectory for thinking about creativity and its role in our society. In1992, James Carville, a strategist to Bill Clinton, coined the powerful phrase, “It's the economy, stupid”. It still is, but what that economy means and who it serves has changed radically in the past 25 years.

We are more interconnected, intertwined, inter-reliant than ever before. Yet social and economic division mar efforts to establish real collaboration and effect real change. It may be the economy, but it’s all the other things too. There has, arguably, never been such a pressing time for creative solutions – and thus the thinking that takes us beyond the creative economy and into new spaces where creativity can be in the service of solution.

There are some serious shortcomings of current prescriptions around the creative economy. These include its neo-liberal character, declining public spending on arts and culture, and the shortcomings of relying on the creative class for social reform, among other challenges.

We are working on developing a call for papers for the conference that explores these and other issues as an important route to delving into ‘The Problem with the Creative Economy’. This is one of the most critical discussions we can have right now.

A conversation problematizing the creative economy also adds value to other debates, such as how we map out the creative economy – and really describe its nuances and dimensions. In addition, as the new White Paper on Arts, Culture and Heritage is being recrafted, it is important to consider the real problems with base conceptualisation – and then of course operationalisation – of the creative economy and indeed policy in regard to arts, culture and heritage in South Africa.

As already indicated in the recent mid-term budget, and given the current development trajectory, there will be probably not, in real terms, be much increasing state support for the ACH sectors. Rather there is likely to be a gap between what is proposed and what is implemented.  However, the discourse and debate assumes increased and widespread state support.

During my European visit, I found during a definite decrease in state overall support for spending in the ACH sectors. So in a sense the creative economy – especially one that is organic, and market-orientated – is a policy response to this process or trend. We also need to consider how economies/savings are to be made in an environment of enforced frugality. This does not necessarily entail a purely neo-liberal solution, but would require a more thoroughgoing invocation of non-state actors, especially the third sector. 

So how do we achieve smart state intervention or growth on a (limited) budget? When rent-seeking is added to the mix how do we conceptualize and research the creative economy most especially in developing and transitional economies? These are questions we will ask at the #SACOConf2018. We need your voice in this – so please start thinking of how you can add to these debates and discussions and join us for the conference.

Update on SACO Activities

The SACO Domain Workshop series drew to a close in October and again was a fundamentally critical process of engagement and learning for both us and for the practitioners. Unathi Lutshaba, our Research Manager, has worked on an interesting summary of the concerns raised and insights gained. This will contribute to the development of our conference call for papers and also a report on the domain workshops.

Our research process is also well underway. We are working on five main reports which overall will contribute to the mega mapping study commissioned. 

  1. Cultural and Creative Industry Employment Report (using LSF data)
  2. International Trade & Cultural Goods
  3. Shifting Ownership and Transformation
  4. Provinces, location and clusters
  5. Macro-economic Report

The research will be published in the coming months, so watch this space.

 Until then, enjoy the October edition of The Cultural Observer.

 Your Culturalist,

Prof. Richard Haines

South African Cultural Observatory: CEO

Heritage, connection and collaboration Heritage, connection and collaboration

GREETINGS from Toulouse. I am in France building stronger international relations with French institutions. It was also Heritage Month in September and we have been considering the importance of heritage in the arts, culture and heritage matrix. At the South African Cultural Observatory (SACO) heritage is a critical consideration for us and in general for the country, and specifically for the Department of Arts & Culture.

Celebrating Creative Women Celebrating Creative Women

WOMEN are, in many ways, shaping the future of the creative industries. Last year Prof Jen Snowball, SACO Chief Research Strategist, compressed data from National Mapping Study of the creative and cultural industries released in 2014, and published this article in The Conversation – From the stage to the boardroom: South African women make slow transition.


Changing the world Changing the world

NELSON Mandela once said: ‘I was not a messiah, but an ordinary man who had become a leader because of extraordinary circumstances.’ In July the incredible leader was front and centre as we not only celebrated his birthday through the now globally renowned 67 Minutes and Mandela Day initiative, but also in the re-naming of Nelson Mandela University.

Young, free and creative Young, free and creative

YOUNG people will shape the cultural and creative economy of the future. While they have always been at the forefront of the culture and content of cool, now more than ever it is important to consider the value, power and role of the youth in building and sustaining this economy.


More News
Aspire Art Auctions makes history in latest sale Aspire Art Auctions makes history in latest sale

Auction house fetches highest ever South African price reached for Kentridge drawing and world record for Kumalo sculpture.

SA Cultural Observatory announces 3rd international conference to be held in Nelson Mandela Bay: ‘Beyond the creative economy?' SA Cultural Observatory announces 3rd international conference to be held in Nelson Mandela Bay: ‘Beyond the creative economy?'

THE future of creativity and its role in our society will be a key focus area of the South African Cultural Observatory’s (SACO) third national conference, which returns to Nelson Mandela Bay in March 2018, the research institute announced today. Embracing the theme ‘Beyond the creative economy? Trends and Issues in National and Regional Economies’ the 2018 conference will run over two days on 7 and 8 March 2018, at the Nelson Mandela Bay Stadium in Port Elizabeth.

Visual intro to the SA Cultural Observatory Visual intro to the SA Cultural Observatory

WANT to know more about the South African Cultural Observatory (SACO) and what it does, but don't have much time? The SACO has just released a new, short(ish) introduction to the organisation on YouTube.

Domain workshop presentations available Domain workshop presentations available

THE South African Cultural Observatory (SACO) has just wrapped its nation-wide tour and is offering all the presentations given as open source information for those who could not attend the workshops.

Gender Equality Policy in the Arts, Culture and Media – Comparative Perspectives Gender Equality Policy in the Arts, Culture and Media – Comparative Perspectives

GERMANY is still lagging behind its neighbours when it comes to women in culture and media, according to a comprehensive survey of the role of women in the arts, culture and media in selected European countries, carried out by the Hertie School of Governance under the academic direction of Helmut K. Anheier, and supported by the German government’s Commissioner for Culture and Media.

Connect with us